The Valley Signal

Source document

TCR, LLC v. Teton County, Docket No. 49487

Idaho Supreme Court · · Court opinion


Open the PDF

Originally published by Idaho Supreme Court: the original, as we copied it October 11, 2026.

What's in it

  • The Idaho Supreme Court's substitute opinion in TCR, LLC v. Teton County, Docket No. 49487, filed Nov. 19, 2024, written by Chief Justice Bevan; it withdraws the court's prior opinion of Jan. 11, 2024. The appeal came from Seventh Judicial District Judge Steven W. Boyce.
  • TCR, LLC sued the county after the Board of County Commissioners refused to record a condominium plat for Lot 12B in the Teton Creek Resort planned unit development, first platted in 1995, alleging breach of a 1996 settlement agreement and seeking declaratory and injunctive relief.
  • The court affirmed the district court's order that the county record the plat under the Idaho Condominium Property Act, finding that the board had twice approved plat amendments for the lot in 2018 and 2019, and held TCR is entitled to have the plat recorded in a form that lets it obtain building permits.
  • It reversed the summary judgment for the county on TCR's breach of contract claim, vacated the dismissal of its claim for breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, and remanded for further proceedings.
  • TCR was awarded attorney fees and costs on appeal. Justices Moeller and Meyer concurred; Justice Zahn dissented in part, on the 2022 motion to enforce and the breach of contract claim.
  • Hall Angell & Associates, LLP argued for the county and Beard St. Clair Gaffney for TCR.

Cited in