The Valley Signal

Government & Accountability

The Victor Valley Collective: Who Runs It, Who Funds It, Where Its Money Went

The Victor Valley Collective is the PAC formed by Victor's recall organizers. Who runs it, who funds it, and where its money has gone.

By Wade Williams

·


VICTOR — The Victor Valley Collective is the political action committee formed by the residents who pushed Mayor Will Frohlich to resign. Carol Nowakowski, who filed the recall petition, chairs it. Paul Merrill is its treasurer and its largest donor. Its biggest expense to date is $5,000 to the law firm that represents one of its founding members in a fee claim against the City of Victor.

This page tracks the committee through its public filings with the Idaho Secretary of State and is updated as new reports post. Figures below run through its October monthly report, filed Nov. 9.

Who runs it

The Collective is registered as a political committee in Teton County. Nowakowski chairs it and Merrill, of Teton Springs, is treasurer. Its website, victorvalleycollective.org, lists eight founding members: Nowakowski, Merrill, former Teton County commissioner Cindy Riegel, Marcia LeMire, Lynda Baxis, Allen Stewart, Amy McCarthy and Marcia Dyer.

Nowakowski led the recall from the start. Her petition was filed March 10 over the city's $35 million wastewater borrowing and its lawsuit against Driggs, and organizers turned in more than 300 signatures in May. Frohlich announced June 24 that he would resign effective July 1, which ended the recall.

Nowakowski announced the committee in a June 27 opinion column on behalf of the Victor Watch Dogs, the informal group behind the recall. She wrote that it would "support candidates who represent constituents over developers," press for "transparent and lawful governance," and "organize the everyday citizens" of the valley. The council members "that enabled these decisions ... remain in place," she wrote, and "the real work ... is just beginning." Mike Geraci answered in a Valley Signal opinion column that the recall reflected "a culture of suspicion, not governance."

The website describes the committee's target as "the growth machine," which it defines as "the network of developers, real estate interests, and the politicians they influence."

Two founding members have since sought a council seat. Nowakowski and Riegel were among six residents the council interviewed for Victor's vacant seat in August. It appointed Erica Linnell on a 2-1 vote.

Who funds it

The Collective has raised $9,426.87 from 17 donors.

Merrill has given $5,999.96 across three contributions, nearly two-thirds of everything the committee has raised. His first, $2,000 on June 24, the day Frohlich announced his resignation, was the committee's entire treasury when it first appeared on the state's roster. Merrill lives in Teton Springs, outside Victor's city limits.

Riegel gave $300 the same day and is the only current or former officeholder among its donors. Amy McCarthy has given $864.44 across three gifts and David Haar of Tetonia $500. Ashley Coletti, who joined Nowakowski as a plaintiff in the lawsuit over Victor's wastewater-plant annexation, gave $103 on Sept. 22. Nowakowski has given $200. The rest are gifts under $300, most from Victor addresses.

Where its money went

The Collective has spent $7,755.30. One payment accounts for nearly two-thirds of it: $5,000 on Sept. 28 to Bailey & Glasser LLP, which the committee's September report lists under "Wages, Salaries, Benefits, & Bonuses."

Bailey & Glasser represents Riegel and Kevin and Rachel Kirchner, the three residents who opposed Victor's petition asking a court to confirm about $35 million in borrowing for a wastewater plant of its own. When Victor dropped that plan and withdrew the petition July 1, the firm sought its clients' legal fees from the city. Victor's special counsel put the claim at about $56,000 if the city settled and $69,000 or more if the firm filed, and the council called an emergency meeting over it on July 14.

The committee's filing does not say what the $5,000 paid for.

The rest of the Collective's spending is smaller. It paid $961.20 to the Bronze Buffalo in Teton Springs for an event on June 30 and $950 to Globe Willow Design of Driggs on Sept. 29, listed as broadcast and internet advertising. Smaller payments went to Squarespace for its website, to Sticker Mule and Peak Printing for printing and signs, and to card processors and its bank. It had $1,671.57 on hand at the end of October.

Before the Collective: the Victor Watch Dogs

The Collective is the recall organizers' first registered committee. The recall effort before it filed nothing.

During the recall, the "Victor Watch Dogs" name appeared on a saturation mailer, paid for by Greg Davis, that told readers to "sign the petition for a recall election," and on an April 4 open house at the Wildwood Room. The recall group did not register "Victor Watch Dogs" with the Secretary of State, and no committee registration or independent-expenditure report for the mailer or the event is on file, as The Valley Signal reported in May. Troy Butzlaff, a contractor to the city, filed a campaign-finance complaint over it on April 29; the state referred it to the Teton County clerk. Nowakowski wrote in June that the recall was "not funded by outside interests" and had "no money behind" it.

Coletti separately runs a GoFundMe, "Defend Our Community: Say No to Rezoning," which raised $19,200 from 95 donations for legal fees opposing Victor's annexation and rezoning of the Evans parcel, the planned site of a wastewater plant of its own. Victor rescinded the Evans land deal and repealed the annexation on April 30, undoing the annexation the suit challenged. The fund's total has not changed since May, and its page gives no accounting of what the legal fees came to. It says that if the fund raises "more than the amount needed to cover legal fees, the rest will be donated to the Teton Valley Health Care Foundation." The Valley Signal has not documented any of the fund's money going to the recall or the Collective.

What's next

Idaho holds city elections in November of odd-numbered years, so Victor's next council election is in November 2027. The Collective files a monthly report with the Secretary of State; the next, for November, is due in early December. This page will be updated as it posts.

Disclosure: Valley Signal LLC, which publishes The Valley Signal, holds the assumed business name "Victor Watchdogs," filed with the Idaho Secretary of State, and the domain victorwatchdogs.com. The recall group did not register the name.

Free newsletter

The Morning Signal

Teton Valley news, once or twice a week. The reporting is airtight. The introduction is unhinged.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.

Sources for this story