The Valley Signal

Source document

Smallwood v. Little, Idaho Supreme Court opinion, Jan. 22, 2026

Idaho Supreme Court · · Court opinion


Open the PDF

Originally published by Idaho Supreme Court: the original, as we copied it October 14, 2026.

What's in it

  • The Idaho Supreme Court's opinion in Docket No. 52011, filed Jan. 22, 2026, written by Justice Moeller, with Chief Justice Bevan and Justices Brody, Zahn and Meyer concurring. The appeal came from Seventh Judicial District Judge Steven W. Boyce in Teton County.
  • The case concerns three parcels in Teton County, once a single farm of about 310 acres, whose deeds bar the grantees from selling, trading, conveying or encumbering the land during the lifetimes of the grantees or their heirs then living, except to the owners of the other two parcels or their heirs.
  • The district court had granted summary judgment upholding the restrictions, concluding that Idaho Code 55-111A abrogated the common law rule against unreasonable restraints on alienation.
  • The Supreme Court held that the common law rule has not been abrogated in Idaho and that the deed restrictions violate it because they are unreasonable.
  • It vacated the judgment, reversed the summary judgment and remanded, awarding costs to the appellants. Rigby, Andrus & Rigby Law, PLLC represented the appellants and Moulton Law Office of Driggs the respondents.

Cited in