---
title: Teton County Denies the Midway Substation a Second Time
url: https://valleysignal.com/growth-land-use/teton-county-denies-the-midway-substation-a-second-time/
publisher: The Valley Signal
author: Wade Williams
section: Growth & Land Use
tags:
- Midway Substation
published: '2026-11-10'
updated: '2026-11-11'
summary: Teton County commissioners voted to deny Fall River Electric's second Midway substation application, finding it incompatible with the homes around it.
license: Content may be cited with attribution to The Valley Signal (valleysignal.com). For republication or licensing inquiries, contact noise@valleysignal.com.
---

# Teton County Denies the Midway Substation a Second Time

DRIGGS — Teton County commissioners voted Monday to deny Fall River Electric's second application for the Midway substation. They found that the substation would not be compatible with the homes around it and that its effects on those homes could not be mitigated.

Commissioner Dan Powers made the motion, and he and Commissioner Ron James voted for it. When the chair called for votes against it, Commissioner Brad Wolfe, who had voted against the first denial in March, said he had raised his hand in favor.

The board cited the same two standards when it denied the first Midway substation application 2-1 in March, on the same parcel near 700 W. 3500 S. Fall River asked the board to reconsider, then withdrew the reconsideration in May, saying it needed a study its first application had lacked. It refiled on the same parcel in August with a wildlife study and 4.25 acres of permanent open space, and the county Planning and Zoning Commission recommended approval 4-3 on Sept. 8. On Oct. 26 the commissioners closed the hearing without deciding and asked planning administrator Joshua Chase to compare the competing studies.

Chase opened Monday's item by naming those two standards as the "two points of contention." The effect on property values, he said, was "one of the biggest questions still in my mind."

James said he had read estimates that a substation could lower nearby home values anywhere from 2% to 40%. "2% is not a big deal. 40% is huge," he said. "There's not been a single person that spoke against this that said that we don't need this as a county. … I just don't like that location. … I just would love for them to find a different location. Make me really happy. And then I'd do everything I could to support them and get it built as fast as they could. But just not there."

"I don't buy the EMF argument, I'll be honest," Powers said, and on wildlife, "I think they've done a good job of mitigating." But, he said, "what it comes down to, really, to me is … the code says the use has to be compatible." He read from the county's comprehensive plan, which he said calls for protecting rural property values and for "clumping industrial uses together." "I don't think it meets the definition of compatibility," he said.

In March, the board's written decision recorded that Wolfe "felt he could support approval of the application if there was a way to adequately mitigate visual impacts and noise." On Monday he said that with a 10-foot wall behind the landscaping, "the noise and EMFs would probably not be an issue." "But the big issue I have again is like everybody else," he said. "The value of the property. How do you mitigate that? The research I did and the legal questions I asked says that our code doesn't allow us to award any monetary figure to anyone based on this."

Wolfe also pictured a winter outage that freezes and breaks water lines. "Everyone's going to be, excuse me, pissed off at us because we didn't pass this and didn't provide life safety electricity," he said. "Can all these conditions be mitigated?" he asked. "I think the answer is no, they're not." He called himself "really on the fence," a case of "damned if you do and damned if you don't."

"No comment at this time as we need to determine what will be our next steps," Fall River said in an email Tuesday.

What to watch: The board will adopt its written decision on a later agenda. After the written decision, Fall River has 14 days to file for reconsideration.

**Correction, Nov. 11, 2026:** An earlier version of this article said the commissioners voted 2-1, with Commissioner Brad Wolfe voting against the denial. During the vote, Powers and James voted in favor. During the 'Opposed?' vote, Wolfe said he had raised his hand in favor. We attributed this to the confusion around double negatives frequently encountered at meetings where the vote is in favor of the motion to deny the application versus in favor of the application. We'll let the minutes sort the tally out on this one. 


---

## Sources

- [BOCC Staff Report, Fall River Electric Special Use Permit](https://valleysignal.com/documents/teton-county/2026-10-26-fall-river-substation-sup-staff-report/)
- [BOCC Written Decision, Apr. 13, 2026](https://valleysignal.com/documents/teton-county/2026-04-13-written-decision-fall-river-substation-sup/)
- [Idaho Code § 67-6535](https://legislature.idaho.gov/statutesrules/idstat/Title67/T67CH65/SECT67-6535/)
- [Teton County Denies Midway Substation Permit](https://valleysignal.com/growth-land-use/teton-county-denies-midway-substation-permit/)
- [Fall River Withdraws Midway Substation Reconsideration](https://valleysignal.com/growth-land-use/fall-river-withdraws-midway-substation-reconsideration/)
- [Fall River Refiles the Midway Substation on the Parcel It Was Denied](https://valleysignal.com/growth-land-use/fall-river-refiles-the-midway-substation-on-the-parcel-it-was-denied/)
- [Teton County Puts Off a Midway Substation Decision as All Three Commissioners Voice Doubts](https://valleysignal.com/growth-land-use/teton-county-puts-off-a-midway-substation-decision-as-all-three-commissioners-voice-doubts/)
