---
title: Driggs Council Takes Up Draft Wastewater Deal for Victor
url: https://valleysignal.com/government-accountability/driggs-council-takes-up-draft-wastewater-deal-for-victor/
publisher: The Valley Signal
author: Valley Signal Staff
section: Government & Accountability
tags:
- Waste Water
published: '2026-11-16'
summary: Victor sent Driggs five areas of protections Nov. 2. The Driggs draft wastewater contract going to its council Nov. 17 sets rates and exit on Driggs' terms.
license: Content may be cited with attribution to The Valley Signal (valleysignal.com). For republication or licensing inquiries, contact noise@valleysignal.com.
---

# Driggs Council Takes Up Draft Wastewater Deal for Victor

DRIGGS — The Driggs City Council on Tuesday takes up a draft contract its staff wrote to make Victor a customer of the Driggs wastewater plant. Two weeks earlier, Victor Mayor Sue Muncaster sent the Driggs mayor, staff and all four council members a list of protections Victor's council members generally agreed any such deal should include. In the draft, Driggs sets the rates each year, Victor's share of the plant is fixed, and neither city can give notice to leave for 10 years. The draft has no independent audit, no way to settle disputes and no terms for the trunk line that carries Victor's sewage to the plant.

Public Works Director Jay Mazalewski calls the draft "NOT a final version, but instead a starting point" in his [staff report](https://library.municode.com/id/driggs/munidocs/munidocs?nodeId=9aa61442b7163). The council is to give feedback, and the draft then goes to Victor "for their comments."

The staff report opens: "The City of Victor requested a draft agreement for wastewater treatment, which Driggs staff has drafted." Driggs first offered Victor a draft in July, and in October Driggs officials had [the customer agreement ready](https://valleysignal.com/government-accountability/victor-asked-to-meet-on-a-facilitator-driggs-had-a-contract-ready/) when Muncaster agreed to take it to her council.

Muncaster's [Nov. 2 letter](https://valleysignal.com/documents/city-of-victor/2026-11-11-mayors-facilitator-emails/2026-11-02-1643-sue-muncaster-435cde/) summed up Victor's Oct. 28 work session in five areas: economic protections, capacity guarantees, risk and liability, accountability, and shared infrastructure. It said it was "not intended to represent a negotiated position or formal Council consensus." "There are two equally useful outcomes from this next step," she wrote. Either the Driggs draft "demonstrates that a customer agreement can provide the protections Victor needs," or "it becomes clear that those protections cannot reasonably be provided within a customer relationship."

"The central principle coming out of our recent Council discussion was that responsibility should correspond to control," the letter says. "If Driggs owns and operates the plant and makes the major operational decisions, Victor is uncomfortable bearing open-ended financial, operational, or regulatory risks for our ratepayers arising from decisions it does not control."

## Rates

Victor asked for "a clearly defined maximum starting rate" and "reasonable limitations on future rate increases." The Driggs draft has formulas for each fee and no dollar figures. Victor would pay the Driggs base and flow rates times a multiplier, and both multipliers are left blank: "1.__ times." Driggs "will annually adjust and set rates at the start of each fiscal year" and tell Victor the new rates by July 1. Nothing caps the increases, and Victor has no say in them. The staff report notes that Driggs "cannot set fees/rates to make profit," and the draft has Driggs keep a "separate revenue, expense, and reserve account solely for the Wastewater Facility."

Late payments carry interest of "2.5%, compounding monthly," about 34.5% over a year. A missed payment "shall be deemed a breach of this agreement" and subjects Victor to termination.

## Capacity

Victor would get "a reserved maximum capacity exclusive for its use," set at 45% of the current plant and 45% of the expanded plant Driggs expects to open in December 2030. "45% is the current percentage flow coming from Victor and matches the historic percentage," the staff report says.

The flow figure for the current plant doesn't match that share. The draft's current-plant table is headed "45% of the current facility's capacity," and its flow row gives Victor 585,000 gallons a day of the plant's 900,000, which is 65%. The same table gives Victor 2,455 equivalent residential units at 165 gallons a day each, or about 405,000 gallons. The 585,000 figure is also Victor's winter allocation at the expanded plant.

If Victor's flow or loading tops 85% of its share, Victor must plan within 90 days to buy more capacity or cut its flow. Victor's letter asked for "clear remedies if promised capacity cannot be provided." The Driggs draft has none.

## Liability

Victor's letter asked that Victor not be "responsible for plant failures, negligence, permit violations, fines, or costs arising from actions outside Victor's control," and that it remain "responsible for issues directly attributable to its own collection system or actions." The draft makes Driggs "responsible for all capital, operating, regulatory, and maintenance expenses" for the plant, "unless otherwise stated herein." Victor pays its part of those expenses through the rates: the flow rate is Driggs' "annual budgeted maintenance costs" divided by the year's estimated flow. The Driggs draft says nothing about plant failures, negligence or fines.

Each city runs its own collection system, and if Victor's system causes the plant to violate state or federal rules, the draft says that "may constitute a breach." Victor must adopt Driggs' wastewater standards "or substantially similar" ones.

## Audits, disputes and exit

Victor asked for "independent review or auditing of cost allocations and billing." The cities' [2011 agreement](https://library.municode.com/id/victor/munidocs/munidocs?nodeId=7d5d969039d49) required an independent audit of the plant's books at least once a year, with the two cities splitting its cost. The Driggs draft has no audit clause, and it "shall supersede and repeal all prior agreements" on its subject.

Driggs may check Victor's meter "at any time" and ask for Victor's connection counts. Victor gets copies of the lab results on samples of its own wastewater, and "backup calculations" when it is billed a surcharge.

Victor asked for "effective dispute-resolution procedures." The draft provides no mediation or arbitration. A city in default gets a written demand and "thirty (30) days to come into compliance," and then the other city may end the contract. The city that sent the demand "shall retain all legal and equitable remedies available to it."

The contract runs 20 years, with one 10-year extension if both cities agree in writing. "After ten (10) years from the Agreement's effective date," either city may give notice, and Victor stays a customer for five more years or until it builds its own plant. The staff report counts the 10 years differently: "Victor must be on the new facility for a minimum of 10-years (2031-2041)." If Victor hasn't disconnected after five years, the draft says, "the applicable Driggs Rates shall be multiplied by three (3) prior." The sentence ends there.

## The trunk line

Victor's letter asked who owns, maintains and pays for "the trunkline, lift station, and other shared facilities," and what Victor's interest is in treated effluent and water rights. The draft's Article II, headed "Trunk Line," reads in full: "NEED TO FILL OUT THESE SECTIONS OR CREATE A SEPARATE AGREEMENT." The lift station, effluent and water rights aren't mentioned.

The staff report says the agreement "applies to wastewater treatment, it does contemplate the trunkline, existing debt service or other outstanding issues. These will be addressed if the cities can work out a framework for treatment."

## What staff said Nov. 6

Mazalewski previewed the draft at a Nov. 6 special meeting. He had been "looking at a couple of draft customer agreements we presented in the past," he said, and working to update them. Asked whether Victor's protections could be addressed, he said: "Yes, we did receive a request from Mayor [Muncaster]. I've reviewed it. Not really digging into that at this point, but I'm going to try. My goal is to address as many of those points in the agreement, this draft agreement. But parallel to the agreement, I'm going to have a separate definition or explanation of each section and how the City of Driggs feels it addresses those issues or those concerns."

The Nov. 17 staff report gives an "explanation/analysis of critical sections." Each entry states staff's objective for the section. None refers to Victor's letter.

Mazalewski also put a question to his council: "How do we want to present… what we come up with to the City of Victor?" He added, "I don't want to make mistakes we've made in the past with providing agreements to Victor and somewhat summarily rejected because there wasn't a proper presentation or an explanation." And: "This way or no way was how it was received in the past."

The draft is a discussion item at the Driggs council's 6 p.m. meeting Tuesday, Nov. 17, with no vote scheduled. Victor's council meets Wednesday, Nov. 18, at 6 p.m., with the customer agreement and facilitation options on its agenda as an action item.

---

## Sources

- [Driggs staff report and draft wastewater treatment customer agreement, Nov. 17 council item 4.e](https://library.municode.com/id/driggs/munidocs/munidocs?nodeId=9aa61442b7163)
- [Muncaster to the Driggs mayor, staff and council, Nov. 2, 2026](https://valleysignal.com/documents/city-of-victor/2026-11-11-mayors-facilitator-emails/2026-11-02-1643-sue-muncaster-435cde/)
- [Driggs and Victor mayors' wastewater letters, July 2026](https://valleysignal.com/documents/city-of-victor/2026-07-15-mayor-to-mayor-wastewater-letters/)
- [Driggs/Victor Inter-City Agreement for Wastewater Treatment Services, 2011](https://library.municode.com/id/victor/munidocs/munidocs?nodeId=7d5d969039d49)
- [Driggs City Council Special Meeting, Nov. 6, 2026](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IhKa2lo8GWY&t=1853s)
- [Driggs City Council agenda, Nov. 17, 2026](https://library.municode.com/id/driggs/munidocs/munidocs?nodeId=9a97b8bcc35d7)
- [Victor City Council special meeting agenda, Nov. 18, 2026](https://library.municode.com/id/victor/munidocs/munidocs?nodeId=9a9a229446630)
- [Victor Asked to Meet on a Facilitator. Driggs Had a Contract Ready.](https://valleysignal.com/government-accountability/victor-asked-to-meet-on-a-facilitator-driggs-had-a-contract-ready/)
- [Victor and Driggs Hand Their Wastewater Agreement to an Outside Facilitator](https://valleysignal.com/government-accountability/victor-and-driggs-hand-their-wastewater-agreement-to-an-outside-facilitator/)
